Meine Merkliste

France: talking therapy for the nation

euro|topics-Wahlmonitor Startschuss für die Schicksalswahl Starting shot for key elections Klimastreiks The climate strikes and the EU elections campaign Müssen die Briten wählen? Imagine it's time for the European elections – and the British have to vote Immer mehr Esten wählen online More and more Estonians voting online Im Wahllokal mit dem Uploadfilter abrechnen Upload filter: Settling scores at the polling station Rumänien: Ein Referendum als Wahlköder? Romania: A referendum as bait for voters? Spanien: Die Katalonien-Frage verdrängt alles Spain: How the Catalonia issue is eclipsing all other themes Frankreich: Ein Land macht Gesprächstherapie France: talking therapy for the nation Opposition in Ungarn wohl chancenlos Opposition in Hungary without a chance Polen: EU-Skeptiker auf Europakurs Poland: Eurosceptics on track for Europe Italien: Das Duell der Egomanen Wie stark werden die Rechtspopulisten? How strong will the right-wing populists be? Beeinflusst der Kreml die russischen Wähler im Baltikum? Is the Kremlin influencing Russian voters in the Baltic states? Tschechien und Slowakei: Eishockey, schlechte Lebensmittel und die Politik The Czech Republic and Slovakia: Ice hockey, Nutella and politics Migration: Wie wichtig ist das Thema noch? Migration: how relevant is the topic? Europawahl: Wer gewinnt, wer verliert? European elections: the winners and the losers Rumänen stimmten gegen Korruption The Romanians voted against corruption Wie geht es weiter mit dem Brexit? Brexit: What comes next? Ist die Ära Tsipras am Ende? Is the Tsipras era coming to an end? Europawahl 2019: Neue Macht für Macron? European elections 2019: More power for Macron? Japan auf dem Weg ins 21. Jahrhundert English version The Romanians voted against corruption European elections 2019: More power for Macron? Japan auf dem Weg ins 21. Jahrhundert Is the Tsipras era coming to an end? Brexit: What comes next? European elections: the winners and the losers Migration: how relevant is the topic? The Czech Republic and Slovakia: Ice hockey, Nutella and politics Is the Kremlin influencing Russian voters in the Baltic states? Poland: Eurosceptics on track for Europe How strong will the right-wing populists be? Opposition in Hungary without a chance Spain: How the Catalonia issue is eclipsing all other themes France: talking therapy for the nation Upload filter: Settling scores at the polling station Romania: A referendum as bait for voters? Imagine it's time for the European elections – and the British have to vote More and more Estonians voting online Starting shot for key elections The climate strikes and the EU elections campaign Redaktion

France: talking therapy for the nation

Nina Henkelmann

/ 3 Minuten zu lesen

France's President Macron has tried to appease the angry "yellow vest" protesters with a nationwide debate, the "grand débat". Has he succeeded in time for the EU Parliament election campaign?

France's President Macron attending the debate at Sainte-Croix-De-Verdon on the 7th of March 2019. (© picture-alliance, Duclet Stéphane/MAXPPP/dpa)

In the second half of 2018 it seemed that the tide had suddenly turned against Europe's rising star Emmanuel Macron: there was the Externer Link: Benalla affair, a series of ministerial resignations, plummeting poll ratings and to top it all the anger of the citizens, who since mid-November have been protesting against the French president and social injustice wearing high-visibility Externer Link: yellow vests. After four Saturdays of violent protests the Jupiter in the Élysée Palace finally reacted, agreeing to comprehensive concessions: the Externer Link: suspension of fuel tax rises, a minimum wage increase, tax cuts. In addition to gifts from the state coffers, Macron presented an innovative concept for dialogue: a Externer Link: nationwide debate. In an open letter he invited his fellow citizens to take part in online discussions or attend local meetings dealing with taxes and the budget, state organisation, energy policy and democracy.

As soon as he announced his plan, voices of resistance cried out from the opposition: Macron would use the civic dialogue to campaign for the European elections at the state's expense, they claimed. Some media joined in the criticism, but others took a more positive view of the idea: "Who would have thought at the start of November that France would turn into a huge forum? Thank you, yellow vests and Emmanuel Macron, for raising this expectation and making it possible for the country to have its say," the daily newspaper Externer Link: La Croix commented approvingly. According to official figures around one million French citizens took part in the discussions. But as the debate drew to an end Externer Link: Le Monde concluded that its impact had been limited: "The great national debate has not brought any major changes. What it has done is make clear the devastated state politics is in."

During the evaluation phase the great expectations that had been placed in the grand débat withered. According to Externer Link: Le Point disappointment was inevitable since Macron would never be able to please the yellow vests anyway: "When we see the disdain of the yellow vests for concessions to the tune of ten to twelve billion euros, and how they immediately dismissed the civic debates as a sham and a diversionary manoeuvre, one cannot but doubt they will be satisfied with reforms that will inevitably be deemed too timid or financially inadequate."

The measures Externer Link: finally announced by the French head of state on April 25 were described by Externer Link: Libération as "tentative reforms that by no means introduce a sixth republic, but allow the fifth one to breathe more freely". Externer Link: Mediapart, however, was critical of the outcome: "This was less a new start than a correction of methods," it wrote, arguing that all Macron really wants is "to press ahead with the neoliberal reconstruction of the country, counting on tax cuts to restore peace and calm before his hopes of full employment by 2025 are realised." Macron is focussed on the Externer Link: European elections, France 24 underlined: "He has advocated the idea of an annual parliamentary debate on migration policy, called for a reform of the Schengen Area and mentioned 'a political Islam that wants to divide our republic'. But immigration, borders and the fight against radical Islamism are subjects that were barely mentioned by the French in the grand débat. Nevertheless, Emmanuel Macron is making them central issues in the upcoming European elections."

With the French left so fragmented and weakened, Macron sees his most dangerous opponents on the right: Marine Le Pen's Rassemblement National, which is more or less neck and neck with Macron's list in the polls, and the conservative Républicains, who thanks to their lead candidate François-Xavier Bellamy are making headway once more.

is the euro|topics correspondent for France and the Francophone communities of Luxembourg, Belgium and Switzerland. She studied Romance languages and literature, cultural studies and communication in Germany and France, and works in media and publicity, language teaching and translation in Germany, France and Italy.