Meine Merkliste

Migration: how relevant is the topic?

euro|topics-Wahlmonitor Startschuss für die Schicksalswahl Starting shot for key elections Klimastreiks The climate strikes and the EU elections campaign Müssen die Briten wählen? Imagine it's time for the European elections – and the British have to vote Immer mehr Esten wählen online More and more Estonians voting online Im Wahllokal mit dem Uploadfilter abrechnen Upload filter: Settling scores at the polling station Rumänien: Ein Referendum als Wahlköder? Romania: A referendum as bait for voters? Spanien: Die Katalonien-Frage verdrängt alles Spain: How the Catalonia issue is eclipsing all other themes Frankreich: Ein Land macht Gesprächstherapie France: talking therapy for the nation Opposition in Ungarn wohl chancenlos Opposition in Hungary without a chance Polen: EU-Skeptiker auf Europakurs Poland: Eurosceptics on track for Europe Italien: Das Duell der Egomanen Wie stark werden die Rechtspopulisten? How strong will the right-wing populists be? Beeinflusst der Kreml die russischen Wähler im Baltikum? Is the Kremlin influencing Russian voters in the Baltic states? Tschechien und Slowakei: Eishockey, schlechte Lebensmittel und die Politik The Czech Republic and Slovakia: Ice hockey, Nutella and politics Migration: Wie wichtig ist das Thema noch? Migration: how relevant is the topic? Europawahl: Wer gewinnt, wer verliert? European elections: the winners and the losers Rumänen stimmten gegen Korruption The Romanians voted against corruption Wie geht es weiter mit dem Brexit? Brexit: What comes next? Ist die Ära Tsipras am Ende? Is the Tsipras era coming to an end? Europawahl 2019: Neue Macht für Macron? European elections 2019: More power for Macron? Japan auf dem Weg ins 21. Jahrhundert English version The Romanians voted against corruption European elections 2019: More power for Macron? Japan auf dem Weg ins 21. Jahrhundert Is the Tsipras era coming to an end? Brexit: What comes next? European elections: the winners and the losers Migration: how relevant is the topic? The Czech Republic and Slovakia: Ice hockey, Nutella and politics Is the Kremlin influencing Russian voters in the Baltic states? Poland: Eurosceptics on track for Europe How strong will the right-wing populists be? Opposition in Hungary without a chance Spain: How the Catalonia issue is eclipsing all other themes France: talking therapy for the nation Upload filter: Settling scores at the polling station Romania: A referendum as bait for voters? Imagine it's time for the European elections – and the British have to vote More and more Estonians voting online Starting shot for key elections The climate strikes and the EU elections campaign Redaktion

Migration: how relevant is the topic?

Ulrike Christl

/ 3 Minuten zu lesen

According to the most recent Eurobarometer polls the topic of migration is less important that it has been in recent years. Europeans have other topics are on their minds.

A man is seen holding a sign reading "EU: Stop War not People" during the "Don't let refugees drown" demonstration on April 21st 2019 in Amsterdam. (© picture-alliance, NurPhoto)

For a long time it seemed as if there were no more than one topic in Europe: migration. Everything pointed to the 2015 refugee crisis and the resulting discussions about migration policy tearing Europe apart. To take the pressure off countries such as Greece and Italy, which were the worst hit by migration, the EU Commission sought to introduce mandatory distribution quotas – incensing countries like Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania … and Britain. They refused to take in the stipulated number of refugees – or sometimes any at all.

But if migration has placed highly or even taken top spot in public opinion since 2015 according to Eurobarometer, other topics have gained in importance since 2017. In the most recent Externer Link: Eurobarometer survey of March 2019, 50 percent of EU citizens were most concerned about the Union’s economic development, while 49 percent put youth unemployment at top spot. Migration came third at 44 percent. Climate protection is also increasingly important: in seven EU countries respondents gave climate issues highest priority.

Emigration a huge concern for some countries

A Externer Link: study put out by the think tank European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) at the start of 2019 indicates that still other topics are of high concern for EU citizens – often outstripping migration. Countries in Central Eastern and Southern Europe have been particularly hard hit in recent years by mass exodus, a phenomenon that has also taken its0 toll on those who stay behind.

Emigration and immigration in the European Union (Interner Link: download illustration). Lizenz: cc by-nc-nd/3.0/de/

In Hungary, Romania, Poland, Greece, Spain and Italy more people are worried about emigration by their own population than about the arrival of immigrants from other countries, according to findings by the ECFR together with the polling institute YouGov. Research for the study was carried out in the 14 most populous countries of the EU excepting Britain.

In the Bulgarian daily Externer Link: Trud demographer Petar Ivanov explains how difficult the situation is in his country: "It sounds terrible but in Bulgaria the death bells are ringing. The country is currently experiencing the worst demographic crisis in its entire history. It is already dead from a demographic point of view. We are disappearing at a faster rate than in any other country in the world. We have the highest mortality rate. In the last nine years we have moved up from 19th place to first place, ahead of countries like Syria and Afghanistan where wars are raging.”

Hungary trying to up its birthrate

Meanwhile the Hungarian government has now also recognised the problem. In answer to emigration and the decline in the birth rate, however, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has chosen to focus less on immigration than on Externer Link: incentives encouraging the local population to have more children. Every woman under 40 who marries for the first time is to receive a loan of ten million forints (roughly 30,000 euros), according to the plan.

While pro-government media back the policy, critics see it as an attempt to keep women in the kitchen. For the Swedish daily Aftonbladet: "Hungary is already known for its brutal refugee policy, its Islamophobia and the open anti-Semitism of its leading politicians. Gender studies have been banned there, and the media are controlled. Now comes the next step: the role of women is being changed and the clocks are being turned back.” By contrast Hungarian daily Magyar Hírlap is delighted: "Today already five percent of the GDP is spent on the nation's main objective - family support. That's more than anywhere else in Europe. The result: the Externer Link: birth rate is rising once more, as is the number of marriages, while the mortality rate remains stable."

Migration problem still unsolved

But even if the topic of migration is now less important for EU citizens than it once was politicians should not lose sight of it altogether, the daily Externer Link: Die Welt insists: "A huge number of people are irate at the EU’s inability to reach a joint solution to immigration and asylum. The old Dublin Procedure is dead. The EU needs a stable, standardised procedure for legal immigration. It’s been talking about it for 25 years. Who now hast he strength to slice this knot?"

is editor for euro|topics.