Meine Merkliste Geteilte Merkliste

Effect of remittances on poverty, income distribution and growth

Kurzdossiers "Paradise Left Behind" – Begleitmaterial zum Film "Es geht um differenzierte Bilder." – Ein Gespräch über Paradise Left Behind Die ägäischen Inseln: von Räumen des Transits zu Räumen der Immobilisierung 'Schengen', 'Dublin' und die Ambivalenzen der EU-Migrationspolitik. Eine kurze Geschichte Paradise Left Behind Migration und Wirtschaft Die wirtschaftlichen Auswirkungen von Zuwanderung Wie sich Migration auf die Herkunftsländer auswirkt Migrantische Ökonomien in Deutschland Fachkräfteengpässe und Arbeitsmigration nach Deutschland Migration und Handwerk – kurze Geschichte einer langen Verbindung Migration und Handwerk: Fachkräftemangel und integratives Potenzial Zugehörigkeit und Zusammenhalt in der Migrationsgesellschaft Was ist Heimat? Warum es so viel leichter ist über Nudelsalat zu reden als über Rassismus Die blinden Flecken antirassistischer Diskurse Was hält eine Gesellschaft zusammen? Was hält eine Gesellschaft zusammen? Konfliktbearbeitung ist der Klebstoff der Demokratie Sozialer Zusammenhalt und das Gefühl, fremd im eigenen Land zu sein Die Gruppe der Ostdeutschen als Teil postmigrantischer Integrationsfragen Kommunale Migrations- und Flüchtlingspolitik Der "local turn" in der Migrations- und Asylpolitik Kommunen und ihre Rolle bei der Flüchtlingsaufnahme Kommunale Aufnahme von Flüchtlingen Interview: Migrations- und integrationspolitische Debatten im Deutschen Städtetag Kommunale Integrationspolitik in Deutschland: Teilhabe vor Ort ermöglichen Zufluchtsstädte im amerikanischen Einwanderungsföderalismus Migration in städtischen und ländlichen Räumen Geflüchtete in ländlichen Räumen Perspektive Geflüchteter auf das Leben auf dem Land Landlust oder Landfrust? Fleischindustrie Migrantische Arbeitskräfte in der malaysischen Palmölindustrie (Il)legal? Migrant_innen in der spanischen Landwirtschaft Das Wachstum der Städte durch Migration Migration und Männlichkeit Männlichkeit im Migrationskontext Muslimische Männlichkeit Väterlichkeiten Intersektionale Diskriminierung Sozialisation junger Muslime Migration – Kriminalität – Männlichkeit Migration und Sicherheit Einführung Migration und menschliche Sicherheit Foreign Fighters "Gefährder" Smart Borders Grenzkontrollen: Einblicke in die grenzpolizeiliche Praxis Die Polizei in der Einwanderungsgesellschaft Interview Radikalisierung in der Migrationsgesellschaft Schlepper: Dekonstruktion eines Mythos "Racial Profiling", institutioneller Rassismus und Interventionsmöglichkeiten Migration und Klimawandel Umwelt- und Klimamigration: Begriffe und Definitionen Zur Prognose des Umfangs klimabedingter Migrationen Der Zusammenhang zwischen Klimawandel und Migration Indikator für Verwundbarkeit oder Resilienz? Klimawandel, Migration und Geschlechterverhältnisse Rechtliche Schutzmöglichkeiten für "Klimaflüchtlinge" Interview mit Ulf Neupert Frauen in der Migration Migration qualifizierter Frauen in der EU Selbstorganisation geflüchteter Frauen* "Gastarbeiterinnen" in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland Ein Überblick in Zahlen Migration und Geschlechterrollen Frauen auf der Flucht Interview Zahlenwerk: Frauen mit Migrationshintergrund in Deutschland Integrationskurse Geschlechtsbezogene Verfolgung – Rechtlicher Schutz Geflüchtete Frauen in Deutschland Kinder- und Jugendmigration Zahlenwerk Kindertransporte Die "Schwabenkinder" Kinder- und Jugendmigration aus GB Menschenrechte von Kindermigranten Third Culture Kids Kindersoldat_Innen Adoption und Kindermigration Kinderhandel Lebensborn e.V. Grenzzäune und -mauern Mauern und Zäune Integrationspolitik Integrationsmonitoring Integrationstheorien Interview mit Andreas Zick Integration in superdiverse Nachbarschaften Migration und Entwicklung Entwicklung und Migration, Umsiedlung und Klimawandel Migration und Entwicklung – eine neue Perspektive? Stand der Forschung Rücküberweisungen Diaspora als Impulsgeberin für Entwicklung Landgrabbing Interview mit Roman Herre Strukturumbrüche und Transformation Diaspora Was ist eine Diaspora? Exil, Diaspora, Transmigration Diaspora: Leben im Spannungsfeld Türkeistämmige in Deutschland Postsowjetische Migranten Polnische Diaspora Vietnamesische Diaspora Kurdische Diaspora Diaspora als Akteur der Entwicklungszusammenarbeit Russlanddeutsche und andere postsozialistische Migranten Wer sind die Russlanddeutschen? Aussiedler Politische Partizipation von Russlanddeutschen Russlanddeutsches Verbandswesen Religiosität unter Russlanddeutschen Interview mit Peter Dück Russlanddeutsche in Russland Russlanddeutsche transnational Jüdische Kontingentflüchtlinge und Russlanddeutsche Transnationalismus als Beheimatungsstrategie Aushandlungen der Zugehörigkeit russlanddeutscher Jugendlicher Mediennutzung der russischen Diaspora in Deutschland 'Russische' Supermärkte und Restaurants in Deutschland Perspektiven auf die Integration von Geflüchteten in Deutschland Arbeitsmarktperspektiven von Geflüchteten Interview mit Gesa Hune Meinung: Geflüchtete fördern - oder es kann teuer werden Effekte der Fluchtmigration - Interview mit Prof. Dr. Herbert Brücker "Die müssen die Sprache lernen" Fremd- bzw. Zweitspracherwerb von Geflüchteten Die Arbeitsmarktintegration Geflüchteter in der Vergangenheit "Wohnst Du schon – oder wirst Du noch untergebracht?" Inklusion in das Schulsystem Ein Jahr Integrationsgesetz Interview mit Prof. Dr. Julia von Blumenthal Über die Zusammenhänge von Religion und Integration Interview: Digitale Bildungsangebote als Chance für Integration Innerafrikanische Migrationen Konsequenzen der Auslagerung der EU-Grenzen Kindermigration in Burkina Faso Flucht und Vertreibung Migranten als Akteure der Globalisierung Migrations- und Fluchtpfade Marokko Libyen Abschiebungen nach Afrika Leben nach der Abschiebung Flüchtlingslager Begriff und Geschichte des Lagers Orte der dauerhaften Vorläufigkeit: Flüchtlingslager im globalen Süden "Das Leben im Flüchtlingslager wird zur Normalität" Urbanisierungsprozesse Kleine Geschichte der Flüchtlingslager Lager in der Weimarer Republik Schlotwiese Uelzen-Bohldamm Friedland Zirndorf Marienfelde Das Jahr 2016: Ein Rückblick Globale Flüchtlingskrise hält weiter an Diskussion um kriminelle Geflüchtete Europa Literatur Resettlement Was ist Resettlement? Historische Entwicklung Resettlement durch UNHCR Resettlement im Vergleich zu anderen Aufnahmeprogrammen Aufnahme und Integration EU und Resettlement Deutschland Zukunft des Resettlements Literatur Akteure im (inter-)nationalen (Flucht-)Migrationsregime Akteure in Migrationsregimen und das Aushandeln von Migration Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge Die Europäische Grenzschutzagentur Frontex Die Asylagentur der Europäischen Union: neue Agentur, alte Herausforderungen UNHCR UNRWA – das UN-Hilfswerk für Palästina-Flüchtlinge im Nahen Osten Die Internationale Organisation für Migration (IOM) "Migration ist ein globales Thema, auf das es auch globale Antworten geben sollte." Flucht und Asyl: Grundlagen Abschiebung in der Geschichte Deutschlands Wie ist das Asylrecht entstanden? Das Asylverfahren in Deutschland Schutzanspruch im deutschen Asylverfahren? Sichere Herkunftsländer Das Konzept "sichere Herkunftsstaaten" Definition für Duldung und verbundene Rechte Flüchtlingsaufnahme und ihre Folgen Fluchtziel Deutschland Freiwillige Rückkehr Unbegleitete minderjährige Geflüchtete Abschiebung – Ausweisung – Dublin-Überstellung Begriff und Figur des Flüchtlings in historischer Perspektive Zivilgesellschaftliches Engagement Ehrenamtliches Engagement von Geflüchteten Interview mit J. Olaf Kleist Engagement in der Migrationsgesellschaft Politische Proteste von Geflüchteten Proteste gegen Abschiebungen Zivilgesellschaft und Integration Städte der Solidarität – ein Interview Beim Kirchenasyl geht es um den Schutz des Einzelnen. Ein Gespräch. Zivilgesellschaftliche Initiativen für sichere Fluchtwege – ein Überblick Migrantenorganisationen – vielfältige Akteurinnen gesamtgesellschaftlicher Integration (Flucht-)Migration und Gesundheit Medizinische Versorgung Interview David Zimmermann Definition von Migration Gesundheitszustand von Migranten Barrieren/ Prävention Erklärungsmodelle Schlussfolgerungen Literatur Das Jahr 2015: Ein Rückblick Fluchtmigration: Hintergründe Verwaltungs- und Infrastrukturkrise EU: Reaktionen auf die Fluchtzuwanderung Flüchtlingszahlen weltweit Internationale Studierende Einleitung Bildungsmigration Internationale Studierende Internationale Studierende in Deutschland Übergang in den Arbeitsmarkt Literatur Migration und Pflege Einführung Altern in der Migrationsgesellschaft Interview mit Helma Lutz Deutsche Asylpolitik und EU-Flüchtlingsschutz Einleitung Flüchtlingsrecht Asylrecht, Flüchtlingspolitik, humanitäre Zuwanderung Flucht und Asyl als europäisiertes Politikfeld Asyl und Asylpolitik Ausblick Literatur Integration in der postmigrantischen Gesellschaft Einleitung Die postmigrantische Gesellschaft Paradigmenwandel Brauchen wir den Integrationsbegriff noch? Integration als Metanarrativ Notwendigkeit eines neuen Leitbildes Literatur Lifestyle Migration Was ist Lifestyle Migration? Briten in Spanien Einen neuen Lebensstil entdecken Folgen des Residenztourismus Zusammenfassung Literatur Wahlrecht und Partizipation von Migranten Einleitung Politische Rechte und Kommunalwahlrecht Wahlrecht für Drittstaatsangehörige Einbürgerung Aktuelle Entwicklungen Schlussbemerkungen Literatur Frontex und das Grenzregime der EU Einleitung Frontex – Fragen und Antworten Die Entwicklung des europäischen Grenzregimes Externalisierung Technologisierung Grenzwirtschaft/border economies Auf der anderen Seite des Grenzzauns Ist Einwanderung ein Risiko? Literatur Demografischer Wandel und Migration Einleitung Demografischer Übergang Deutschland und Europa Internationale Wanderung Integration und Reproduktionsverhalten Wanderungspolitik Regionale Muster Literatur Glossar English Version: Policy Briefs "Having a nationality is not a given, it is a privilege" Sanctuary and Anti-Sanctuary Immigration Law in the United States Migrant Smugglers Urbanizing Skilled Female Migrants in the EU Self-Organization of Women* Refugees Impact of Migration Revisited Child and Youth Migration Human Rights Protections Migration from the United Kingdom Adoption and Child Migration Third Culture Kids Trafficking in Children Actors in National and International (Flight)Migration Regimes UNHCR UNRWA International Organization for Migration The International Organization for Migration (IOM) German Asylum Policy and EU Refugee Protection Introduction Refugee Law Asylum Law, Refugee Policy, Humanitarian Migration Flight and Asylum Current Developments Current and Future Challenges References Integration in a Post-Migrant Society Introduction Post-Migrant Society Paradigm Shift Do We Still Need the Concept of Integration? Integration as a Metanarrative Need for a New Concept References Lifestyle Migration What Is Lifestyle Migration? British in Spain Realizing a New Style of Life Outcomes of Lifestyle Migration Conclusion References Voting rights and political participation Introduction Political and Municipal Voting Rights Voting Rights for Nationals of Non-EU States Naturalization Recent Developments Conclusions References Frontex and the EU Border Regime Introduction Frontex — Questions and Answers The Development of a European Border Regime Externalization Technologization Border Economies On the Other Side of the Border Fence Is Migration a Risk? References Demographic Change and Migration in Europe Introduction Demographic Transition Germany and Europe International Migration Reproductive Behavior Migration Policy Regional Patterns Glossary Further Reading Global Migration in the Future Introduction Increase of the World Population Growth of Cities Environmental Changes Conclusion: Political Migration References Germans Abroad Introduction Germans Abroad Expatriates in Hong Kong and Thailand Human Security Concerns of German Expatriates Conclusions References Migrant Organizations What Are Migrant Organizations? Number and Structure Their Role in Social Participation Multidimensionality and the Dynamic Character Interaction with their Environments Between the Countries of Origin and Arrival Conclusion References EU Internal Migration EU Internal Migration East-West Migration after the EU Enlargement Ireland United Kingdom Spain Portugal Greece Italy Germany Assessment of Qualifications Acquired Abroad Introduction Evolution of the Accreditation Debate The Importance of Accreditation Basic Principles Thus Far of the Accreditation of Qualifications Acquired Abroad Actors in the Accreditation Practice Reasons for Establishing a New Legal Framework The Professional Qualifications Assessment Act What Is Being Criticized? The Accreditation System in Transition Conclusion References From Home country to Home country? Context Motives Immigration and Integration in Turkey Identification Emigration or Return? References Integration in Figures Approaches Development Six Approaches Conclusion References Climate Change Introduction Estimates Affected areas Environmental migration Conclusion References Dual citizenship Discourse Classic objections Current debate Rule of law Conclusion References Female Labour Migration The labour market Dominant perceptions Skilled female migration Issues Conclusion References How Healthy are Migrants? Definition The Health Status Prevention/Barriers Migration and Health Conclusions References Networks Spain Migrant networks Effects of networks Romanian networks Conclusion References Integration Policy Introduction Demographic situation Economic conditions Labour market The case in Stuttgart Integration measures Evaluation Outlook References Irregular Migration Introduction The phenomenon Political approaches Controlling Sanctions Proposed directive Conclusions References Integration Courses Introduction The Netherlands France Germany United Kingdom Conclusions References Recruitment of Healthcare Professionals Introduction The Situation Health Worker Migration Costs and Benefits Perspectives and Conclusion References Triggering Skilled Migration Introduction Talking about mobility Legal framework Coming to Germany Mobility of scientists Other factors Conclusions References Remittances Introduction The Term Remittance Figures and Trends Effects Conclusion References EU Expansion and Free Movement Introduction Transitional Arrangements Economic Theory The Scale The Results Continued Restrictions Conclusion References The German "Green Card" Introduction Background Green Card regulation Success? Conclusion References Does Germany Need Labour Migration? Introduction Labour shortages Labourmarket Conclusion Labourmigration References Dutch Integration Model The "Dutch model"? The end? Intention and reality A new view Where next? References Impressum

Effect of remittances on poverty, income distribution and growth

Stefanie Hertlein Florin Vadean

/ 7 Minuten zu lesen

Unlike public development cooperation and foreign direct investment, remittances have grown steadily in recent decades and today serve as an important source of revenue in countless households throughout the developing world.

Migrant worker from Mexico in California. (© picture alliance / landov)

Does financial support from migrants represent a step toward solving the problem of poverty in developing countries? Or does it simply place these countries in a new kind of dependent relationship?

Opinions vary greatly as to how remittances affect the fight against poverty, income distribution, spending habits, education, health, investment and growth as well as the balance of payments in developing countries. This is due, in part, to the lack of accurate data and the variety of research methods used to analyse it.

Combating poverty

The influence of remittances on individual recipient household incomes can be seen as a positive one, at least in the short term. The principle advantage of remittances is that they are paid directly to individuals and families. Unlike state- controlled development assistance and direct investments from foreign countries, the money does not flow into companies and other organisations. Rather, it raises available household income, which in turn enables families to meet their own specific needs. It must be emphasised, however, that it is difficult to draw a direct comparison between remittances and the above-mentioned sources of development-related financing: Remittances represent a source of private capital, and it is therefore solely at the discretion of the migrants and their families to decide on the money's use.

Mexico's National Population Council (CONAPO) estimates that 1.4 million Mexican households benefited from remittances in 2004. For beneficiaries, this financial influx represents, on average, 47% of the family income. Similarly, the Philippines has come to the consensus that households receiving remittances are financially better off, because they average a monthly income that is 45% above the national minimum wage. In addition to increased income, remittances also offer beneficiaries a certain amount of security. While foreign direct investments have been especially subject to fluctuation, remittances have served as a stable, steadily increasing financial inflow to developing countries since 1990 (see Figure 1). Due to their consistency even during economic troughs, remittance payments offer recipients an extremely reliable source of income. Anti-cyclical increases are common, i.e. migrants abroad increase the scope of their family support during times of economic crisis. Such behaviour helped buoy the Philippine economy during the Asian financial crisis. It was possible to avoid a recession solely through a surge in remittances, which sustained domestic consumption and helped the country overcome a slump in exports. Following Hurricane Mitch in 1999, El Salvador's government used this behaviour to its advantage, asking its citizens living in the US to increase support to families back home.

The immediate increase of available family incomes is a vital means of support, especially for middle- to low-income households. This added income not only increases recipients' living standards, it also minimises vulnerability during times of crisis or natural disasters.

Income distribution

A comparison of data from different case studies does not reveal a consistent pattern concerning the effects of remittances on income distribution; in some cases, it even reveals conflicting results. These variations can be attributed, in part, to traditional patterns of migration. As a rule, individuals from the middle class tend to migrate first, as only they can afford the high costs involved. As soon as migration networks are established, the cost of migrating decreases significantly, making it possible for poorer groups of people to emigrate. It is assumed that remittances reflect this migration trend and, therefore, temporarily increase income disparities in the sending countries. At first, remittances from middle-class migrants increase the level of income in middle-class households, widening the income gap, before poorer households are able to improve their income by sending a family member abroad.

Spending habits

The improved income situation enjoyed by recipients of remittances also brings with it changes in spending habits. Additional financial resources are used primarily for daily expenditures, home construction, land purchase, medical care and education. A smaller fraction of the money is saved and possibly invested. The majority of funds, however, are used to cover ongoing living expenses. For a long time it was believed that spending on consumption did not generate lasting economic development. Current economic studies now tend to deviate from this line. The increase in household spending is now said to stimulate ongoing demand for consumer goods and services, which, in turn, triggers production and results in the creation of new jobs. This theory has already been supported by economic analysis which shows that increases in spending have a multiplier effect (see below).

The second largest expenditure target is home and land ownership. Although this tends to have a positive effect on the construction sector, it may have some negative consequences. In Egypt, for example, the price of land for agricultural purposes increased 600% between 1980 and 1986. This increase in demand was due, in part, to remittances. Such growth in demand for non-tradable goods like property and real estate can lead to a rise in inflation. Similarly, negative effects can occur if domestic production cannot keep up with the increased demand. This can result in an increase in imports and/or an appreciation of the exchange rate, impairing domestic production as exports become more expensive on the international market and, as a result, less competitive. However, strong fluctuations of this sort have not been proven empirically.

Education and health

Many experts see the main value of remittances in improved education and health. A considerable portion of remittance spending goes to educating young relatives back home. A number of studies have already shown significant improvements in the educational level of younger generations. For example, the increased cash flow to the Philippines during the financial crisis in Asia led to a significant increase in school enrolment, a decline in child labour as well as a general increase in spending on education. Estimates for El Salvador indicate that remittances, as compared to other sources of income, reduce the likelihood that urban children will quit school early by 10%.

It is difficult to measure the real effect of increased health-related spending. For example, it remains to be seen whether Mexico´s migration trends alone are responsible for decreases in child mortality and increased birth weights, or whether this is also due, in part, to other factors. The most important migration-related benefits in the fields of health and education are – in addition to increased financial support – the heightened awareness and knowledge of these issues that migrants gain by living abroad.

Investment

Another crucial component of sustainable development is the accumulation of real capital, which requires new investments. In this context, remittances could produce the greatest impulse for the creation of capital and labour market expansion in developing countries if they were used to finance entrepreneurial activities. However, this type of spending tends to occur least often. Studies show that in Mexico, for example, 95% of monetary remittances are spent on consumption and a mere 5 to 8% saved for future investments. Despite this low level of savings, remittances do seem to have a positive effect on the creation of new businesses in Mexico. A study conducted on small businesses in urban areas of Mexico revealed that remittances account for nearly 20% of total capital stocks.

However, the relatively widespread criticism that remittances contribute very little to sustaining structural improvements and generating development remains valid. Finding ways to increase the proportion of investment spending is certainly a challenge for the future. At the same time, few migrants seem able to make the career move from worker to entrepreneur. It is up to national governments to create a healthy financial sector and an investment-friendly climate so as to increase personal savings (including from remittances) and investments.

Growth

Economic theory considers economic growth, i.e. increase in GDP, a basic prerequisite for escaping the poverty trap. To achieve growth, it is not the size of remittance payments that is important but rather – as argued above – the way in which the additional revenue is put to use. As previously discussed, the effects of savings and investment are greater than that of consumer spending. Nevertheless, consumer spending can also have positive multiplier effects for the economy as a whole. In the case of Mexico, it has been proven that for every dollar entering the country through remittances, the GDP increases by US$2.69 in urban areas and by US$3.17 in rural areas.

On the other hand, at the household level, isolated observations reveal that remittances may have a negative effect on growth. For example, Kenyan farmers with additional income from remittances have lower crop yields than those without financial support from abroad. The paradoxical phenomenon can be traced back to a change in incentives. The so-called moral hazard theory supports the notion that families in this situation no longer have an incentive to remain productive themselves, preferring to direct their energies into attracting support from relatives living abroad. Under these conditions, remittances could lead to a decline in economic growth. However, it is doubtful that such behaviour can be attributed to all individuals. In this regard, it is extremely difficult to gather data concerning this phenomenon.

Balance of payments

Finally, extreme increases in remittance values have a direct effect on a country's balance of payments. Monetary inflows not only fill the coffers of private households but also lead to an increase in the recipient side of the balance of payments. The entry of foreign currency into the country helps both to reduce foreign exchange shortages and to consolidate the balance of payments. Remittances, in contrast to other incoming payments from abroad, are advantageous, because they neither carry interest nor have to be repaid.

InfoTargeted emigration policy in the Philippines

There are many calls for political strategies to optimise the development potential of remittances. Up to now, only a few countries have developed official strategies pertaining to migration and remittances. The Philippines are among the few countries that, for decades, have managed emigration. Its "Overseas Employment Program" has fostered and regulated temporary labour migration since 1974. In the beginning, many workers were sent on labour contracts to the Middle East on account of the oil boom. The goal was to reduce unemployment in the Philippines and to increase the flow of foreign currency into the country. The current rationale behind the program's continued existence is that it helps combat illegal migration and prostitution, and that it improves working conditions in host countries. According to government figures, more than 7.3 million Filipinos lived abroad in 2004, representing 8% of the country’s population. Remittances received through official channels amounted to 5.2% of the GDP in that year. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait remain the major destinations for Filipino emigrants; however, private and governmental organisations place migrant workers in various countries worldwide. Since 1990, the government, under pressure from the population and external organisations, has been working harder to protect the rights and welfare of Philippine workers abroad. In order to protect migrant workers from exploitation, additional preparation courses for migrants were introduced to explain working conditions and migrants' legal position in host countries. To encourage increased remittance activity, special identification cards with integrated Visa cards and bank accounts were introduced, making the cost of money transfers more reasonable. Transfer fees amount to less than US$3 and exchange rates are subject to market conditions.

Views on Philippine emigration policy are divided. Its means of managing temporary migration are considered exemplary, as no other country has managed to generate such organised and protected migration flows. However, critics note that the stated goal of abolishing irregular emigration has not been met; instead, there seem to be two parallel migration movements. Moreover, the cost of brain drain on Filipino society is significant, and even after nearly three decades of this emigration policy, no lasting change can be observed.

Fussnoten

Stefanie Hertlein studies Geography, Economic Policy and Ethnology at the University of Freiburg.

Florin Vadean is a member of the Migration Research Group at the Hamburg Institute of International Economics (HWWI), a Ph.D. candidate in economics at the University of Hamburg and a Research Fellow at the Research on Immigration and Integration in the Metropolis (RIIM), Vancouver, Canada.